Will epic Hambletonian win be enough to carry Apex to top of divisional honors?

by Brett Sturman

Immediately after he delivered one of the all-time great harness racing wins in this year’s Hambletonian, Apex reigned supreme in the 3-year-old male trotting division and, for that matter, tops in the entire sport. Last year’s Dan Patch winner at 2, Apex seemed easily destined for at least a repeat of that award at 3 following that 1:49.2 Hambletonian stakes-record win over Big Ranger in early August.

Fall, however, has told a different story. Apex has won just once in six starts following that Hambletonian sparkler and in that time other horses in the division have staked later season claims of their own. What voters must first ponder is how much weight the Hambletonian is worth in a season that still goes for three months after.

History suggests a strong correlation between Hambletonian winners and eventual divisional winners, though there have been some exceptions including a recent one which mirrors this year’s divisional race.

Beginning arbitrarily in 2004, Windsong’s Legacy kicked off a streak where for six years in a row the Hambletonian winner was the divisional winner. All told going back 21 years between that year and this one, the same holds true for 14 out of the last 21 Hambletonian winners. Within those 14 winners includes Atlanta and Ramona Hill who won the stake as fillies and are included since they won divisional honors as trotting fillies.

The only horses during that span who won the Hambletonian and didn’t win their division that same year were Nordic Catcher S (2025), Karl (2024), Captain Corey (2021), Forbidden Trade (2019), Perfect Spirit (2017), Trixton (2014), and Muscle Massive (2010).

When including caveats, that list gets even smaller. Nordic Catcher S and Captain Corey had their seasons (and in the case of Captain Corey, career) end prematurely due to injury following their Hambletonian wins. Perfect Spirit was elevated to his Hambletonian win when first-past-the-post What The Hill was disqualified, and What The Hill did in fact go on to win the divisional awards that year.

The case for Apex rests not just on the Hambletonian win but also with the summer he put together leading up to it. Key wins during that time included the NJSS Platinum final (over Diabolic Hill) and the Stanley Dancer (over American Power and Inexpressable). In his second start following the Hambletonian coming a month later on Sept. 11, Apex won the NJ Classic final (over Nix Nacken). With a record this year of 11 5-3-0, Apex ends the year with $971,803, the division’s top earner.

If not Apex, it seems like it’s his less-heralded stablemate Nix Nacken who has the strongest resume. Beginning in the summer months, Nix Nacken notched smaller but notable wins in the New Jersey Sires Stakes Silver final, as well as the $200,000 Earl Beal consolation, and a NJ Classic elimination (over Magic Punk and Diabolic Hill). He was a first-over runner-up to Apex in the following week’s NJ Classic final. But it’s in the fall where Nix Nacken really made his case.

On Sept. 26 in the Grade 1 Canadian Trotting Classic, Nix Nacken went a big first-over mile and this time did get the better of Apex, when he upset the heavy favorite at odds of 12-1. Then, just one week later in Lexington, Nix Nacken, being overlooked once again, won the Kentucky Futurity, this time at odds of 17-1. Perhaps there being a sense that he wasn’t at his best, Apex drifted in odds well off his morning line, and on cue broke stride at the start of that race.

Following his Futurity win, Nix Nacken would close out the year to be second in both his Breeders Crown elimination and in the final. In his final seven starts of the year, he won four of those and was no worse than second. Through that winning span, he somehow had five different drivers. He finishes the year the same as Apex with five wins, and similar earnings, coming in at $910,266.

The way this year has played out closely parallels 2024, where Karl was dominant after winning the Hambletonian, but Sig Sauer ultimately took the division.

Sig Sauer beat Karl twice that year and, similar to Nix Nacken and Apex, did so both times in upset fashion. The first was a 65-1 upset in the Stanley Dancer, and the second time came in the Kentucky Futurity when he won at odds of 9-1. Interestingly, in recent years when the Dan Patch winner wasn’t the Hambletonian winner, it’s often the Kentucky Futurity that became the next most important race. In the case of Sig Sauer, he was able to parlay his Kentucky Futurity win into a Breeders Crown win.

Who should win the award and who will win the award are two different questions. Does the fall resume of Nix Nacken outweigh the summer one of Apex? It really is close. But one thing for certain is the perception, and maybe even fact, that regardless of resumes, Apex is the better horse. Marcus Melander trains both horses, and following Nix Nacken’s win in the Canadian Trotting Classic, was quoted as saying “He’s [Apex] obviously been the better horse, and is probably the better horse. But he got beat fair and square today.”

I believe that notion will persist in voter’s minds.

Not having won a race all year in a snake-bitten season until Oct. 8, I don’t think Diabolic Hill can win the year-long award in a span of less than one month, but he did finish hot. Following an overnight win at Harrah’s Philadelphia in early October, he broke through in his Breeders Crown elimination (over Apex) and then won the final (over Nix Nacken), before finishing up with a win in the Matron at Dover. An honorable mention can be given as well to Inexpressable, a winner of the Yonkers Trot as well as the $300,000 Earl Beal final (over Diabolic Hill).

There’s no question that Apex delivered the best race of the year. We’ll find out soon if he was deemed also to have delivered the best season.