Highland Holdings pursues Hawthorne OTB franchises

by Neil Milbert

Although Hawthorne Race Course has ceased to exist as a racetrack it retains off-track betting franchises and they are up for grabs.

If nothing happens, they will go out of business on Jan. 1.

Bids of at least $3,215,000 are due on Monday (Nov. 23) on the real estate that is the site of an OTB location in the Chicago suburb of Crestview, leased OTB outlets, and any other assets that remain following the $90 million sale of the track for real estate development that closed the first week in September.

The $90 million falls light years short of the amount that Hawthorne owes its multitude of creditors.

If needed, an auction will be held on Tuesday (Dec. 1); Friday (Dec. 4) is the sale objection deadline; and a sale hearing is scheduled for Thursday (Dec. 10). Any transaction must be approved by the Illinois Racing Board by Thursday (Dec. 31). The board’s last scheduled meeting for 2026 is on Wednesday (Dec. 16).

Highland Holdings, a Highland Mills, NY entity that oversees a portfolio of gaming and commercial real estate companies, earlier this month filed a $3 million stalking horse bid.

The bid calls for the sale of the property and assets to three entities: 13148 Rivercrest Crestwood LLC, Highland Downs, LLC, and Crestwood Downs, LLC with $2.9 million going to the real estate property and $100 million to the business assets.

Jeffery Rehberger, chief executive officer of these three entities, said he was told by the Racing Board that there is no process available to obtain a 2027 thoroughbred racing license but a harness racing license could be pursued with the OTB licenses moved as a result.

According to Rehberger, Hawthorne president Tim Carey, Hawthorne Race Course gaming CEO Kevin Kline, and members of the Carey family that owned and operated the track would neither hold equity nor receive equity if the deal is finalized.

Hawthorne Race Course was the thoroughbred license holder, its affiliate Suburban Downs conducted the harness meeting, the Carey family heirs owned the 119-acre site of the track and Post Time Catering was the affiliate with the food and beverage license.

Hawthorne was owned by the Carey family for 134 years and was the last surviving racetrack in the Chicago metropolitan area that once had seven that were flourishing. After being solely a thoroughbred track, it added the Suburban Downs meeting in 1970 and, with some interruptions, conducted harness racing through 2025.

This is the first year since 1945 — the year before pari-mutuel harness racing was legalized in Illinois at Maywood Park — that there have been no meetings in the state (except for the usual brief late summer programs at the State Fairs at Springfield and DuQuoin).

Fourteen programs scheduled for January and February were canceled because of Hawthorne’s inability to pay purses. The track declared bankruptcy on Feb. 27 and the meeting scheduled for Nov. 26-Dec. 27 will not be held because of its sale to a non-racing entity.

After the Illinois legislature allowed tracks to incorporate casino gambling Hawthorne applied for and received a license from the Illinois Gaming Board in 2020 and the demolition process to convert it into a proposed $400 million racino began.

But then the process was halted and, despite yearly assurances by Carey in appearances before the Racing Board that “we’re right on the cusp,” the racino never became reality, leaving an eyesore in the seating area and liens by unpaid contractors.

Several other elements involving the OTB franchise bid by Highland Holdings are in the mix.

Churchill Downs, Inc. filed a limited objection on Nov. 16, stating that it supports the sale but opposes any distribution to another creditor unless its own lien for unpaid simulcast revenue is paid. As of now, Hawthorne has paid $600,000 of the $1,641,371.03 claim.

Woodbine Entertainment, the New York Racing Association, Meadowlands Racing and Entertainment, and Saratoga Harness Racing are other former simulcast partners that have claims.

The Illinois Harness Horsemen’s Association (IHHA), the Illinois Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Association (ITHA), contractors, and unions are also on the long list of entities owed significant amounts of money.

IHHA executive director Tony Somone is holding out hope that one of four groups that want to build a racino in south suburban Chicago and are seeking 2027 standardbred dates will be successful.

Acting on behalf of Highland Holdings, Rehberger is the latest to contact the organization in regard to its proposal. The others expressing an interest are Larry Lucas, Claude Jones, and a group headed by former ITHA president Mike Campbell and Ron Awsumb.

None of the groups said a racino would be ready by 2027 but all said they would work with the Illinois Department of Agriculture to have an extended pari-mutuel meeting at either Springfield or DuQuoin next year.

FINISH LINES: The ITHA this month finalized an award of $700,000 in financial assistance for thoroughbred owners, trainers, and backstretch workers impacted by Hawthorne’s financial turmoil. The thoroughbred meeting that was to run through Nov. 1 began three weeks later than scheduled on April 19 and ended prematurely on July 19.

Of this amount $350,000 is being distributed by the Illinois Backstretch Foundation Assistance Program to help grooms, assistant trainers, hot-walkers, exercise riders, and other backstretch workers affected by Hawthorne’s closure. The other $350,000 is going to owners and trainers who participated in the shortened meeting.

“While no amount of financial assistance can fully compensate for the hardships caused by Hawthorne’s closure these funds will provide a measure of relief to the people who invested their time,  labor, and finances in keeping Illinois thoroughbred racing alive,” a post on the ITHA web-site stated.